Skip to content

"What about Romans 7?"

The objection. "Paul says, 'I do not do the good I want, but the evil I do not want is what I keep on doing' (Rom 7:19). If Paul struggled like that, then a believer can live in ongoing sin and still be saved. Romans 7 proves that struggle is normal and that sin does not jeopardize salvation."

Romans 7 is one of the most debated passages in the New Testament. The casebook does not claim that Christians do not struggle. It claims that the struggle Paul describes is not the same as a settled life of sin.

The text

"For I do not understand my own actions. For I do not do what I want, but I do the very thing I hate... For I do not do the good I want, but the evil I do not want is what I keep on doing... Wretched man that I am! Who will deliver me from this body of death?" (Rom 7:15, 19, 24, ESV)

The debate

There are several readings of Romans 7:

  1. Paul before conversion — the unregenerate person under the law, unable to obey.
  2. Paul after conversion — the believer who delights in the law of God but still struggles with the flesh.
  3. Israel under the law — a corporate reading of the nation's failure.
  4. A rhetorical "I" — Paul speaks in the voice of a person under law, not necessarily his own biography.

The casebook does not need to settle the debate. Even on the reading that Paul is describing a believer, the passage does not teach that a Christian can live in unrepentant sin.

The problems

1. The person in Romans 7 hates the sin

The person Paul describes is not at peace with sin:

  • "I do not do what I want" (v.15) — he wants to do good.
  • "I hate" the evil (v.15) — he hates what he does.
  • "I delight in the law of God in my inner being" (v.22) — he loves God's law.
  • "Wretched man that I am! Who will deliver me?" (v.24) — he cries for rescue.

This is the opposite of the person Hebrews 10 describes, who tramples the Son of God and treats the blood as common. The Romans 7 person is grieved by his sin; the Hebrews 10 person is contemptuous of the sacrifice.

2. The passage is about the law, not a license

Romans 7 is part of Paul's argument that the law cannot save. The law is good, but it cannot produce obedience; it reveals sin and condemns it. The "I" is helpless under the law, and the cry is for deliverance.

The deliverance comes in Romans 8: "There is therefore now no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus... For the law of the Spirit of life has set you free in Christ Jesus from the law of sin and death" (8:1-2). The passage is not a celebration of struggle; it is a cry for rescue that is answered in Christ.

3. Romans 8 gives the resolution

Romans 8 does not say, "Keep struggling; it is fine." It says:

  • "Walk according to the Spirit" (8:4).
  • "Set your minds on the things of the Spirit" (8:5).
  • "Put to death the deeds of the body" (8:13).
  • "If you live according to the flesh you will die" (8:13).

The same letter that describes the struggle commands the believer to put sin to death. The struggle is real, but it is not the end of the story.

4. The New Testament distinguishes struggle from surrender

The casebook distinguishes:

  • Struggle: the believer fights, falls, confesses, and returns. The direction is toward Christ.
  • Surrender: the person makes peace with sin, defends it, and refuses correction. The direction is away from Christ.

Romans 7 is the first. Hebrews 10 is the second. The difference is not the presence of sin; it is the response to it.

5. The "carnal Christian" reading is not Romans 7

The carnal Christian teaching uses Romans 7 to say that a believer can live in unbroken carnality and still be saved. But Romans 7 does not describe unbroken carnality; it describes a war. The person is not comfortable in sin; he is miserable in it. The carnal Christian teaching turns a war into a status.

The abiding reading

Romans 7 teaches:

  1. The law is good but cannot save. It reveals sin and condemns it.
  2. The believer still struggles with the flesh. Struggle is real, and it is not apostasy.
  3. The struggle is painful. The person cries for deliverance.
  4. The deliverance is in Christ. Romans 8 answers the cry.
  5. The direction of the life matters. The person who hates sin and cries for rescue is not the person who has made peace with it.

The casebook does not teach sinless perfection. It teaches that the Christian life is a war, and that the Spirit gives victory in the war — not that the war is over.

What about "I keep on doing"?

The present tense in Romans 7:19 describes a pattern of struggle, not a settled practice. Paul is not saying, "I have decided to keep sinning." He is saying, "I keep failing, and I hate it." The tense alone does not settle the question; the context does. The context is a person who delights in God's law and cries for deliverance.

Pastoral application

If you are struggling with a recurring sin, Romans 7 is for you. It tells you that the fight is normal, that the grief is a sign of life, and that the deliverance is in Christ. It does not tell you that the sin is fine.

If you have made peace with the sin, Romans 7 is not your passage. Hebrews 10 is. The answer is not to manage the guilt; it is to repent and return.

What this does and does not prove

It proves: that believers struggle with sin; that the struggle is painful; and that the deliverance is in Christ.

It does not prove: that a believer can live in unrepentant sin and be safe; that struggle is the same as surrender; or that sin is harmless. It proves that the war is real, and that the Spirit gives victory.

See also